Luckily, we do have service records for James Jefferson R Keller. They show he was mustered in the 10th Alabama Infantry Regiment on March 1st, 1862 at Gadsden, Alabama as a Private. The muster roll also tells us that James was a married 25 year old at the time of enlistment. Farming was listed as his occupation and his residence was marked as Duck Springs, Alabama which is about 10 miles north of Gadsden.
Of the 8 or 9 engagements listed on his unit’s muster rolls, James is only counted present at the Siege of Yorktown (Virginia) fought during April of 1862. The battle was generally inconclusive with the Confederates withdrawing to Williamsburg. I found a requisition form dated April 9, 1862 signed by a Sgt. James Keller of the 10th Alabama at Camp Winder. James had been promoted in the month or so he had been in the army. Camp Winder was at Richmond and served as a hospital consisting of 98 buildings and 125 acres of farmland. The next battle his unit participated in was the Battle of Williamsburg on May 5, 1862. James is not marked present. Presumably he was ill by that time and had been removed to an encampment to recover-- maybe back at Camp Winder. The family gets his letter but he is never heard from again. There are no records for James after April of 1862.
I have since found that James M did have a son named James, but he was James Austil Keller born 13 years after James Jefferson R Keller. I find it unlikely that James M would name two sons James. What seems more likely is that James M could be an uncle or cousin of James Jefferson.
This theory got a boost when we were able to test a Keller family member’s yDNA. In 2015 I contacted Ella Emery (mentioned earlier) about finding a Keller male who might test for us. My grandfather, Bill Keller had all girls, so I knew I would have to reach out to a cousin for this task. Ella was my mother’s first cousin on the Keller side and an established genealogy juggernaut. Ella suggested I contact Hugh Keller of Lonoke, Arkansas. He descends from one of my grandfather’s older brothers and he has an interest in genealogy and, in fact, had already done an autosomal DNA test. Hugh was graciously receptive and a few weeks later we had a Keller yDNA kit at the FTDNA website.
In January of 2016 an email from FTDNA alerted me to a close yDNA match that had shown up for Hugh Keller. It was a Mike Keller from Oklahoma born in 1951. His sister Loretta administered the kit. I emailed Loretta and quickly found that Mike and Loretta descended from James M Keller of the 10th Alabama. Our suspicions were correct. James M is one of our Kellers. The circumstances of the match and the timeframe/ geography of the lives of the two men strongly suggested to me that James M was most likely an Uncle to James Jefferson. James M’s father would be James Jefferson’s grandfather.
Unfortunately, Loretta didn’t know much about James M’s father. James M Keller was their brick wall. He had survived the war and eventually passed away in 1898-- he lived long enough to be recorded in the 1880 census. It’s there we find an interesting tidbit, James M claimed his father was born in “England.” Another clue provided by Loretta is what her family had passed down via oral tradition. From Loretta...
...there is some family lore that I found interesting. I believe this would relate to the father of James M. Keller. My oldest aunt (born 1890’s) indicated she was told that their ancestor was shanghaied by the crew of a ship bound for America. When they reached the Virginia shore he jumped off and swam ashore.Fascinating! We know that James M is of the Kellers that we descend thanks to yDNA testing and we know that our lineage came from England the generation before James M. As far as I know, my branch of the Keller line had passed no such story down. We knew nothing about any ancestor beyond James Jefferson R Keller who died in the Civil War but now we know that it is very likely, James Jefferson’s grandfather came from Britain. The “shanghaied” story is interesting but I’m always hearing how family lore is notoriously unreliable.
Oddly enough in some Keller forum I visited years ago, someone doing research on the James M. Keller lineage said that according to their family lore their ancestor was shanghaied from Ireland by a ship bound for America. When they reached Virginia, the boy jumped ship and swam to shore and hid in the Keller family tobacco fields. He was found by servants of the family and brought to the house. The Keller family took him in and gave him their name. According to her the family that took him in is the line that Helen Keller derives from. As she also pointed out, if family lore proves true, we may not actually be “Kellers” at all.
The month after corresponding with Loretta, I received the following email from another distant Keller cousin-- William Keller of Birmingham, Alabama…
I recently checked my DNA results and found that Hugh Keller and I may be related, because of ties to where they lived. My Keller great great grandfather moved from northwest Georgia to the Conway, Ark., area in the 1850s, before he and his family moved back east to north Alabama in 1860, southeast of Decatur, Ala. That ancestor was Alfred Burton Keller (1829-1910), and we think he had traveled to Arkansas with other members of his family and his wife’s family, the Tilleys. We also think his father was an immigrant from England, probably Thomas Keller, who shows up in Habersham County, Ga., in the early 1800s...After some checking, I found that William Keller (actually the test belonged to his brother Thomas) did show up on Hugh Keller’s yDNA matches but Thomas’ test only included 12 markers. I had been focused on matches that tested 37 or more as they are more predictive of recent common ancestors. Thomas’ match at 12 markers is a good match, but only concludes there is a common paternal ancestor within the last great many umpteen generations. Based on 12 markers our common ancestor could be a 24th great grandfather-- so far back that it’s not particularly helpful. But, it very well could be a more recent ancestor. Our geography of our recent families and the few number of generations since immigration would lead me to conclude the connection is more recent. There is just no way of knowing for sure except by testing more markers.
What I did find eye-opening in William’s email (and I think what he was driving at) is the reference to Georgia and Conway, Arkansas. James Jefferson R Keller’s wife, Harriet Jane and her two sons made this same trip from Georgia to Conway, Arkansas 20 years after William’s ancestor’s family returned to north Georgia. Harriet moved and settled in 1881. One of her son’s returned to North Georgia not unlike Alfred’s family had done. This seems more than coincidental. Some of Alfred Burton Keller’s family did stay in Arkansas and would have been in the area when Harriet arrived- specifically some of his wife’s Tilley family.
William’s Alfred Burton Keller was born in 1828 and died in 1910. He claimed to have been born in Georgia like James M Keller. Interestingly, William’s email mentioned England. After researching Alfred Burton Keller, I found that he recorded twice on federal census forms (1880 and 1900) that his father was born in England. William further conjectured that a Thomas Keller of Habersham County Georgia might be Alfred’s father.
I began to theorize that James M. Keller and Alfred Burton Keller were brothers. They were born about 13 years apart in Georgia to a father born in England. Their descendants match yDNA. This would likely make them both uncles to my James Jefferson R Keller who was born in Georgia 20 years later.
There was another zinger from William’s email. The last paragraph contained this...
...Family legend has it that two Keller brothers jumped ship somewhere on the east coastMy two new cousins, William Keller of Birmingham and Loretta Keller of Oklahoma had no knowledge of each other. They had never communicated. Their families had not been in contact in all likelihood for at least 120 years yet they share a similar family lore. While it doesn’t prove anything, it sure is interesting.
In 1850, James Jefferson R Keller (15 years old) was living with his mother, his maternal grandmother, three brothers and one sister in Franklin County, Georgia. A father for that family was not enumerated in the 1850 census. James’ mother, Mary Ann (Oliver) Keller, was listed as head of household. The youngest brother was born in 1842, so we can assume Mary Ann’s husband (and James’ father) passed away between 1842 and 1850. The 1840 census should reveal a Keller family with 3 boys and one girl, a 32 year old mother and a 30-something father. Unfortunately, the 1840 census only names the head of household. Other members of the household are simply counted and sorted into an age range. It does not name them. So we can’t search for Mary Ann Keller as she was not the head of household.
Bordering Franklin County to the northwest is Habersham County, Georgia founded in 1818. Mary Ann’s mother, the widow Elizabeth Oliver, is found there in the 1840 census in Long’s district with her own household. Two rows down on the same census page we find Wm. M Keller with a family whose ages align with what we would expect of James Jefferson’s family in 1840 with the addition of one female aged 10-14. She would likely be an older sister of James Jefferson or a cousin helping out with chores. I think it is Polly Ann Keller who married Daniel Kester in Franklin county in 1841. Not sure that she is a sister, but seems plausible. On the same census page, five lines below Wm. M. Keller we find "Brazel Addison’s" family counted. James Jefferson’s sister, Rachel Keller, married a son of this Braziller Addison in 1852 just over in Franklin County. These connections are circumstantial but are convincing enough for me to believe William M Keller was Mary Ann’s husband and James’ father.
I’ve only found a couple other documents that may serve as evidence for William M Keller. They are tax role indices. Probate records or land records would be ideal. There is a property tax document from Franklin County (1832) with a William Keller listed. He is listed with Christopher Addison acting as agent. I’m not sure why William needed an agent. Maybe because William was living in the next county and needed someone to handle his affairs in Franklin County? Interestingly, this Christopher Addison’s niece (by marriage) became the spouse of our James Jefferson R Keller. If William M Keller is not James Jefferson R Keller’s father, he sure is running in the right circles.
Given the assumption that William M Keller was James Jefferson's father, it follows that Alfred Burton Keller and James M Keller (the two lines put forward by yDNA evidence) were brothers of William M Keller. It's also possible they were cousins, but both Alfred B and James M's families indicated their father was from England on subsequent census records.
Several of Alfred's descendants found at Ancestry.com indicate that Thomas Keller of Habersham County, Georgia is the father of Alfred. Thomas is found in one census record, the 1830 census of Habersham County, Georgia. Some of his neighbors in that 1830 census include the familiar Addison, and Chaffin families. Coincidentally, I also found our Allen family and Cleveland families listed as neighbors of Thomas Keller although they don't tie in to the Keller line for several generations.
There are a number of factors that point to Thomas Keller being the probable father of our William M Keller other than his familiar 1830 neighbors. Thomas Keller is widely acknowledged as being of English birth, though I haven't found specific proof. He passes the "in the right place at the right time at the right age with the right name" test as well. I think it's also telling that though admittedly common, the names "Thomas," "William," "James," and "George" occur with great frequency in all three families for generations. Because of the foregoing circumstantial evidence, and the fact that our close yDNA cousins have earmarked him, I currently show Thomas Keller as William M Keller's father in my tree...
Naturally, this is a work in progress and subject to change. You will notice some other Kellers in that tree. Delilah and Mahalia Keller were sisters of Alfred B Keller. All three of them married into the Tilley family. This is the family that DNA cousin, William Keller of Birmingham, said went to Conway in the 1850's then most returned to Georgia.
On the left of the above image is the curious addition of Barnett A "Barney" Keller. I added him to my tree because I have found autosomal DNA cousins that descend from him in my list of matches. When I look at the common or "shared" matches of these "Barney Keller" DNA cousins I find, overwhelmingly, known Keller family cousins, so I'm sure Barnett Keller ties in to our Keller family somewhere. I have not found a descendent of Barney who has tested yDNA. That would help immensely.
Like our James Jefferson R Keller, Barney died during the civil war. In 1853, when our James Jefferson R Keller was 18 years old, Barney Keller named a son "James Jefferson Keller." Maybe that name was more common than I figure, but it caught my eye. Barney's son was born in Alexander County, North Carolina. Barney, we believe, was born in Burke County, North Carolina. Though most of what we know about our James Jefferson R Keller's family is out of Habersham and Franklin County, Georgia, his mother, Mary Ann Oliver, was born in North Carolina, so there is some connection with the State.
Much more research is required. The lack of probate and marriage records pertaining to the early Keller families of North Carolina and Georgia is highly frustrating. Hopefully more helpful documents will become available with time and we can nail down some of these relationships. This is where it stands today. I'll be updating as more evidence surfaces.
No comments:
Post a Comment